Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Any Aperture users using DNG?
Luminous Landscape Forum > Raw & Post Processing, Printing > Apple Aperture Q&A
mrtaber
Just wondering. I'm seriously considering it.

Thanks,
Mark
CatOne
QUOTE (mrtaber @ Aug 28 2007, 03:03 PM)
Just wondering.  I'm seriously considering it.

Thanks,
Mark
*


Why? Aperture's DNG support is only "fair." And I have a tough time figuring out what you really actually GET from using DNG over the manufacturer's RAW formats.

I think if you've consumed the DNG Kool-AidŽ you may be better off with Lightroom.
digitaldog
QUOTE (CatOne @ Aug 30 2007, 11:57 AM)
Why?  Aperture's DNG support is only "fair."  And I have a tough time figuring out what you really actually GET from using DNG over the manufacturer's RAW formats.

I think if you've consumed the DNG Kool-AidŽ you may be better off with Lightroom.
*


Yes, I too had some DNG issues with Aperture when just playing around with it to do a review. I'm a Lightroom guy, as you'd expect, it handles DNG's just fine (especially with 1.1).

As for DNG Kool-Aid, there's a lot the format offers. I don't want to deal with sidecar files for one. I like the embedded JPEG (updated for current rendering), the files are smaller and its a far better container to hold all the various bits and pieces than the proprietary Raws. Thomas is working on updating the spec and if all goes well, we'll see some really useful functionality in the format. Think PDF for Raws.
oronet commander
QUOTE (CatOne @ Aug 30 2007, 07:57 PM)
And I have a tough time figuring out what you really actually GET from using DNG over the manufacturer's RAW formats.


I some cases, as Panasonic LX-2, a 50% reduction in file size. And embedded metadata.
brycv
I use DNG frequently with my Pentax K10D PEF RAW files. It decreases the size significantly. I sometimes still keep some PEF RAW files around from time to time but usually only as a backup. I have not found any issues yet.

Bryan
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.