Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: PhaseH25/Mamiya RB67 ProSD or Canon 1DsIII
Luminous Landscape Forum > Equipment & Techniques > Medium Format Digital Backs and Photography
sid_v
hi,

please help me decide if i should buy a refurb H25 for my mamiya RB67proSD or go for a markIII? I have three lenses for the RB ie. 50,90 n 180 all k/l series. I also have a 5D with 3 primes. Cost of the back and 1DsIII is exactly the same.

Qualitywise i'm sure mamiya/phase wins. My only worry is that how long will the back last, it came out in sept 2003. I love the mechanical mamiyaRB n can live with the H25 as i'll be shooting tethered only. Canon seems a safer investment, but it's not medium format.

What should i do?? Also any tips about mechanical body with H25 will also be of help.

thx,
sid.
RicAgu
No Brainer,

I would stick with the RB and H25. The back will last as long as Phase supports the H25 firmware and include in their software.

I used the P series with the RZ and it worked great!

Best of luck.

Pick yourself a used 1Ds Mark II down the line for $2,500

Best of Luck


QUOTE (sid_v @ Feb 1 2008, 02:28 PM)
hi,

please help me decide if i should buy a refurb H25 for my mamiya RB67proSD or go for a markIII? I have three lenses for the RB ie. 50,90 n 180 all k/l series. I also have a 5D with 3 primes. Cost of the back and 1DsIII is exactly the same.

Qualitywise i'm sure mamiya/phase wins. My only worry is that how long will the back last, it came out in sept 2003. I love the mechanical mamiyaRB n can live with the H25 as i'll be shooting tethered only. Canon seems a safer investment, but it's not medium format.

What should i do?? Also any tips about mechanical body with H25 will also be of help.

thx,
sid.
*
clawery
Sid,

What type of work do you shoot? If it's mostly tabletop / product, I would go with the H25. If you shot more location work, I might lean towards the Canon.

Chris Lawery
Title, Capture Integration
Capture Integration, Phase One Dealer of the Year

877-217-9870 | National
404-234-5195 | Cell
Sign up for our Newsletter | Read Our Latest Newsletter
JDG
When you are ready to upgrade in the future, the H25 will hold its value much much better. Its definitely the better financial investment.
sid_v
thnx for the replys guys. H25 seems the way to go. I'm not worried abt the software upgrades/firmware etc as long as it works the way it does now. I'm worried about the ageing electronics. I wouldn't want to buy a 9000$ paperweight.

Chris: I mainly shoot studio/location fashion and advertising. Like i said shooting tethered is not a prob. If i have a p25, i'd shoot it the same way. Why do u still suggest canon. Anything i should know (glitches?)

sid.
clawery
QUOTE (sid_v @ Feb 1 2008, 11:44 PM)
thnx for the replys guys. H25 seems the way to go. I'm not worried abt the software upgrades/firmware etc as long as it works the way it does now. I'm worried about the ageing electronics. I wouldn't want to buy a 9000$ paperweight.

Chris: I mainly shoot studio/location fashion and advertising. Like i said shooting tethered is not a prob. If i have a p25, i'd shoot it the same way. Why do u still suggest canon. Anything i should know (glitches?)

sid.
*



Sid,

I would only say go with the Canon if you need the portability or fast shoot speed. Since you are a studio shooter and don't mind the tethering, I would go with the H25. As it was stated in a previous post, the H25 will maintain it's value longer than the Canon. We have two H25s currently for sale if you are interested. You can PM me or send an e-mail to the address below.

Chris Lawery
Capture Integration - Miami/Atlanta
Phase One Dealer of the Year
404-522-7662 office
404-234-5195 cell
877-217-9870 national
Capture Integration, Phase One Dealer
chris@captureintegration.com
John Schweikert
Chris,

The new website looks really nice.

QUOTE (clawery @ Feb 3 2008, 08:15 AM)
Sid,

I would only say go with the Canon if you need the portability or fast shoot speed.  Since you are a studio shooter and don't mind the tethering, I would go with the H25.  As it was stated in a previous post, the H25 will maintain it's value longer than the Canon.  We have two H25s currently for sale if you are interested.  You can PM me or send an e-mail to the address below.

Chris Lawery
Capture Integration - Miami/Atlanta
Phase One Dealer of the Year
404-522-7662 office
404-234-5195 cell
877-217-9870 national
Capture Integration, Phase One Dealer
chris@captureintegration.com
*
John Schweikert
deleted
clawery
QUOTE (John Schweikert @ Feb 3 2008, 01:44 PM)
Chris,

The new website looks really nice.
*


John,

Thank you! I wish I could take all the credit, but Doug Peterson (from our Miami office) deserves the credit.

Chris Lawery
Capture Integration - Miami/Atlanta
Phase One Dealer of the Year
404-522-7662 office
404-234-5195 cell
877-217-9870 national
Capture Integration, Phase One Dealer
chris@captureintegration.com
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.