Why Photographs Work – a Review

October 13, 2013 ·

Michael Reichmann

One of the most influential books about photographs has been Ansel Adams’s 1983Examples : The Making of 40 Photographs. Though now nearly 30 years old the book remains in print, and is likely found in most serious photographs book collections. I know its long been in mine.

One of the reasons for its success and longevity is that it isn’t just a book of interesting photographs, but in addition provides an insight into the aesthetic and creative challenges presented in their making.

Among my generation I was not fortunate enough to have studied with the likes of Ansel Adams or Minor White. During the 1960’s through 80’s I was too busy traveling the world making a living as a photojournalist and working for TV networks and film productions. But we all are able to learn from great teachers, and for this reason a couple of generations of photographs have been fortunate to have books likeThe Making of 40 Photographsto learn from.

Now there is, in my opinion, a book that will similarly inspire a new generation of photographers. It isGeorge Barr’s Why Photographs Work

Elizabeth Opalenik


The Student and The Teacher

I first metGeorge Barrabout eight years ago when he attended a master class that I was teaching in Ontario, Canada. The group was an experienced one, but when it came time for each attendee to show their portfolio it was clear that George was in a class by himself – literally.

Since then George has blossomed as a photographer, teacher and author in his own right. He has published two previous books,Take Your Photography to The Next Level, and From Camera to Computer.Take Your Photography to The Next Levelwas serialized here onThe Luminous Landscapein 2007.Part One.Part Two.Part Three.

WithWhy Photographs WorkGeorge has, in my view, established himself as one of today’s leading authors in the photographic genre.

Pete Turner

The Photographers

Among the 52 photographers and their work profiled inWhy Photographs Workare some of the big names of the current scene; Bruce Barnbaum, Dan Burkholder, Roman Loranc, John Sexton, Charlie Cramer, and Michael Kenna, to name just a few. But there are more than 40 others, some known, others not. Each is a stand-out though, and George is to be congratulated on the perspicacity of his selections.

Wayne Levin


The Approach

Each photographer’s work is presented by a single image, full page. This is then followed by an analysis of the image by George, an essay by the photographer commenting on their own work, philosophy, style, and equipment. That photographer’s section concludes with a biography and a Technical section mentioning the equipment used.

While the presentation follows a formula it is by no means rigid. The style of each photographer is allowed to shine through, not just via their photography, but through their own words and George’s analysis also some of what makes them the individuals that they are. Knowing what camera was used for a particular shot has its interest, but so much more is to be learned from knowing something of the photographer’s background and passions.

If you buy one photographic book this year I urge you to make George Barr’s Why Photographs Work that one. It’s a book that will greatly reward your investment – not only monetary, but especially in the time to read and absorb each of the entries. I guarantee that it will make you a better photographer.

May, 2011

Michael Reichmann

Michael Reichmann is the founder of the Luminous Landscape. Michael passed away in May 2016. Since its inception in 1999 LuLa has become the world's largest site devoted to the art, craft, and technology of photography. Each month more than one million people from every country on the globe visit LuLa.

You May Also Enjoy...

Polaroid 4000

January 13, 2009 ·

Michael Reichmann

As part of the upgrade of my entire image processing system in 1999 I planned to replace the Nikon CoolScan LS1000, which has been the


April 22, 2013 ·

Miles Hecker

`Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?' -- said Alice `That depends a good deal on where you want